Mary Elizabeth Wieting Johnson | Syracuse Women in Philanthropy

In 1896, the Wieting Theater burned down for a 3rd time, and Mary re-built it again, making it bigger and better, turning it into the number one theater in Syracuse.

Submitted by Gregg Tripoli, OHA

Mary Elizabeth Wieting Johnson
(1843 – 1947)

Mary’s interests were centered on the advancement of education and drama. She was a lecturer, author, and poet and she was married to Dr. John Wieting who built the Wieting Block on the southern edge of Clinton Square, the largest portion of which was the Wieting Opera House – a theater that played host to many lecturers and theater productions of the day. During Dr. Wieting’s lifetime, the Wieting Block burned down twice (in 1856 & 1881) and was twice rebuilt by him.

Upon his death in 1887, his will, which included bequests to many local charities, was declared completely invalid due to tangled legal logistics and Mary inherited his entire estate.

Mary became a businesswoman by retaining and managing the Wieting Block. In the early 1890’s she took a chance on the 16 year-old Sam Shubert and hired him as the treasurer of the theater providing him with the financial experience and the theater-world connections that helped him eventually launch the largest theatrical empire this world has ever known. In 1896, the theater burned down for a 3rd time, and Mary re-built it again, making it bigger and better, turning it into the number one theater in Syracuse. Her business acumen served her well and she greatly enhanced the fortune that John, though somewhat unintentionally, left her.

In 1900, she married Melville Augustus Johnson and moved out of state. Mr. Johnson preceded her in death by several years, at which point she moved back to Syracuse. Upon her death in 1927, Mary made good on the declared invalid bequests of her first husband, John, thus honoring his wishes to provide $5,000 (about $62,000 in today’s dollars) each to St. Joseph’s Hospital, OHA and the Syracuse Home Association, as well as his desire to provide funds for the addition to the Onondaga Orphans’ Home in the form of a hospital to benefit women and children under the age of 18. Mary allotted $100,000-125,000 for this project, naming it the Wieting-Johnson Memorial Hospital. She also added a $5,000 bequest to Crouse Hospital and an additional $50,000 to John’s original Syracuse Home bequest in order to expand the building. The residue of her estate went to Syracuse University, as per John’s original wishes.

So, basically, though she had been living away from Syracuse for over 20 years and though the bulk of Mary’s estate was earned by her in the 40 years since John’s death, her entire estate, with the exception of the additional $5,000 to Crouse Hospital, went to her husband’s designated beneficiaries. It is entirely possible, of course that these were her choice of beneficiaries as well. And, in the end, they are all worthy causes, so does it really matter who chose them? After all – it was Mary’s money to give and it was certainly well given.

An interesting note about Mary’s will was her specific instruction that the fire insurance on all her real estate be kept up to date until it was sold.

Related Stories

women's fund logo
News Releases August 30, 2022

Women's Fund Distributes $50,000 in Grants

$50,000 in grants will assist nonprofits serving Onondaga, Oswego, and Cayuga counties

Jeff Knauss sits with his wife, son and daughter on an outdoor couch on a porch
Stories August 29, 2022

Jeff Knauss: Giving for the Greater Good

Jeff Knauss gives because “it’s the right thing to do—period.” He strives to continue making ...

Caragh Fahy and her two sons stand in from of a playground
Stories August 29, 2022

Caragh Fahy: Giving for Generations

Caragh believes that building a financial plan is like putting together a puzzle and charitable ...

Nikki Jones
Stories June 1, 2022

Black Equity and Excellence: Nikki R. Jones

Nikki R. Jones is creating and trailblazing a path for black women in her community.

News Releases April 11, 2022

Grant Round is Open! | Women's Fund of CNY

The Women’s Fund will award ten $5,000 grants to support programs and ideas that aim ...

Bob Vitkus stands outside
Stories April 5, 2022

Tomorrow's Neighborhood's Today in Action

Dr. Robert J. Vitkus adored the outdoors, and Tomorrow's Neighborhood's Today seeks to continue his ...

Stories April 5, 2022

CNY Arts Grants Support Local Artists

COVID-19 changed the way local artists interacted with their audiences. CNY Arts were committed to ...

Black Media Mogul Maker attendant
Stories April 5, 2022

Excellence in Action: Black Media Mogul Maker

Central New York is bursting with creativity; Black Media Mogul Maker seeks to amplify its ...

Betty and Ted Stark sit in their home
Stories March 30, 2022

Dunbar Disney Dreams: Creating Impact and Opportunity for Syracuse Students

As Betty and Ted Stark believed, this trip had a deeper impact than just visiting ...

women's fund logo
News Releases August 30, 2022

Women's Fund Distributes $50,000 in Grants

$50,000 in grants will assist nonprofits serving Onondaga, Oswego, and Cayuga counties

Jeff Knauss sits with his wife, son and daughter on an outdoor couch on a porch
Stories August 29, 2022

Jeff Knauss: Giving for the Greater Good

Jeff Knauss gives because “it’s the right thing to do—period.” He strives to continue making ...

Caragh Fahy and her two sons stand in from of a playground
Stories August 29, 2022

Caragh Fahy: Giving for Generations

Caragh believes that building a financial plan is like putting together a puzzle and charitable ...

Nikki Jones
Stories June 1, 2022

Black Equity and Excellence: Nikki R. Jones

Nikki R. Jones is creating and trailblazing a path for black women in her community.

News Releases April 11, 2022

Grant Round is Open! | Women's Fund of CNY

The Women’s Fund will award ten $5,000 grants to support programs and ideas that aim ...

Bob Vitkus stands outside
Stories April 5, 2022

Tomorrow's Neighborhood's Today in Action

Dr. Robert J. Vitkus adored the outdoors, and Tomorrow's Neighborhood's Today seeks to continue his ...

Stories April 5, 2022

CNY Arts Grants Support Local Artists

COVID-19 changed the way local artists interacted with their audiences. CNY Arts were committed to ...

Black Media Mogul Maker attendant
Stories April 5, 2022

Excellence in Action: Black Media Mogul Maker

Central New York is bursting with creativity; Black Media Mogul Maker seeks to amplify its ...

Betty and Ted Stark sit in their home
Stories March 30, 2022

Dunbar Disney Dreams: Creating Impact and Opportunity for Syracuse Students

As Betty and Ted Stark believed, this trip had a deeper impact than just visiting ...

View More