Group of teens sitting at a table

Adding New Flavor to Grantmaking with Participatory Budgeting

Giving Voice Fall 2022: Granting Matters

Qiana Williams Headshot
Qiana Williams, Program Officer

Globally, one of the most trending tools for strengthening civic engagement and fortifying communities has been participatory budgeting (PB), an inclusive process that empowers residents to decide how to allocate grant funding through collaborative deliberation and decision-making.

We launched our first PB project this fall to address the issue of childhood lead testing. We identified this priority by using the Life Needs Assessment, a data tool we designed to measure the well-being of our community in real time. It revealed that more than 45% of Syracuse residents have not had their homes or children tested for lead; the PB process will examine how we can increase lead testing of Syracuse children. The winning project(s) will be funded with a pool of $150,000 grant dollars.

People often say that peanut butter and jelly sandwiches come to mind when they first hear about PB, and they are not too far off, metaphorically speaking. Much like the sandwich, we have two layers of professional nonprofit specialists (slices of bread) that sandwich the critical work of neighborhood discernment (the peanut butter and jelly) on either end.

The first slice of bread represents the facilitators and expert presenters who set clear guidelines and expectations for discussion and the generation of ideas. It is this group that makes relevant data available and conducts extensive outreach to recruit residents, usually from historically disenfranchised communities. They make it possible for people to share their different perspectives and daily experiences, much like peanut butter and jelly come from their own separate jars to make their magic when mixed together.

At the center of the PB process are the residents who drive the process by learning about the issues that empower their voices and inspire their ideation for proposals. Then, once ideas are generated and ranked by residents, the process is sandwiched by the second slice of bread in the form of a different set of nonprofit and government professionals who can work the ideas that residents generate into concrete projects that their staff members can carry out. The process culminates in a communitywide vote on the vetted proposals to determine which proposal(s) will be funded.

By spearheading the PB process, we seek to journey with residents to transform our community. In preparation of this project, we conducted extensive outreach over the summer, directly engaging hundreds of residents all around the city through participation and funding of conferences, festivals and fairs. Our participation at more than 20 events has afforded us the opportunity to discuss who we are, the work we do and to recruit residents to participate.

We look forward to working with residents on this unique approach to civic engagement and philanthropy. Those looking to learn more can visit cnycf.org/budgeting.

Related Stories

Pamela Monaco sitting with her dog
Stories November 21, 2022

Giving With Energy & Heart: Pamela Kip Reisman Monaco

It was an “a-ha” moment for Pamela Kip Reisman Monaco when she read another woman’s ...

Peter A. Dunn
Publications November 21, 2022

Point of View

Giving Voice Fall 2022: Point of View

Angela Winfield & Lance Lyons standing outside
Publications November 21, 2022

Forging Pathways for the Future: Angela Winfield & Lance Lyons

Giving Voice Fall 2022: Donor Story

Blogs October 29, 2022

Reflections: Creating a Legacy of Equity

Jan Lane, senior philanthropic advisor, explains the ways that leaving a legacy can help you ...

new hires CNYCF
News Releases October 27, 2022

Community Foundation Announces New Hires

Over the past several months, the Community Foundation has added three new members to its ...

Six young people gather in front of mural at Boys & Girls Clubs
Publications October 6, 2022

Turning the Corner: A Rationale for the Next Step in Our Performance Management Work

Colby Cyrus, CAPM and Frank Ridzi, Ph.D. examine the impact the CNYCF's Performance Management Learning ...

Children standing with paramedic
News Releases September 28, 2022

$240,000 in Grants Awarded to Black-Led Organizations

Seventeen grants from our Black Equity & Excellence Fund totaling $240,000 were distributed to support ...

Pamela Monaco sitting with her dog
Stories November 21, 2022

Giving With Energy & Heart: Pamela Kip Reisman Monaco

It was an “a-ha” moment for Pamela Kip Reisman Monaco when she read another woman’s ...

Peter A. Dunn
Publications November 21, 2022

Point of View

Giving Voice Fall 2022: Point of View

Angela Winfield & Lance Lyons standing outside
Publications November 21, 2022

Forging Pathways for the Future: Angela Winfield & Lance Lyons

Giving Voice Fall 2022: Donor Story

Blogs October 29, 2022

Reflections: Creating a Legacy of Equity

Jan Lane, senior philanthropic advisor, explains the ways that leaving a legacy can help you ...

new hires CNYCF
News Releases October 27, 2022

Community Foundation Announces New Hires

Over the past several months, the Community Foundation has added three new members to its ...

Six young people gather in front of mural at Boys & Girls Clubs
Publications October 6, 2022

Turning the Corner: A Rationale for the Next Step in Our Performance Management Work

Colby Cyrus, CAPM and Frank Ridzi, Ph.D. examine the impact the CNYCF's Performance Management Learning ...

Children standing with paramedic
News Releases September 28, 2022

$240,000 in Grants Awarded to Black-Led Organizations

Seventeen grants from our Black Equity & Excellence Fund totaling $240,000 were distributed to support ...

View More